Skip to Content
Categories:

OPINION: Sweeping Immigration reforms to the Peach State

Georgia House Immigration Bill seeks to allow commissioner of corrections officers access to immigration status
Graphic made in Canva.
Graphic made in Canva.
Yasemin Kalpakci

The Georgia House of Representatives passed the Alien Track and Report Act also known as the Laken Riley Act, a week after the events of Feb. 22, where nursing student Laken Riley was brutally murdered on the University of Georgia Athens campus by undocumented immigrant Jose Antorrio Ibarra.  Georgia House Bill 1105, also known as the Alien Track and Report Act, has been in the making for over a year, but took on a new urgency  after the death of Laken Riley. 

The homicide at UGA should have made national headlines raising some important questions regarding campus safety especially for women. Instead Laken Riley’s story was turned into a political scheme by republicans who argue that harsher security would eliminate crimes committed by illegal immigrants, including this event. 

We can all agree that people who commit crimes, especially violent crimes should face the repercussions associated with that crime. 

A non-citizen being legitimately arrested, should be the reason for them to be flagged for deportation. Especially knowing that prior to the brutal murder of the young student, Ibarra, was arrested by the New York Police Department and released back into the general population regardless of the fact that he was known to be an undocumented immigrant.

The Georgia Immigration bill however, is vague. The ambiguous nature of the bill could lead to illegal seizures and racial profiling in ways that could go against the constitutional rights that legal Americans citizens have.

The Bill clearly outlines that sheriffs and jailers must ask for documentation and arrest anyone suspected of being in the United States, and refusing to follow these new protocols would cause local governments to lose federal funding. The threat of losing funding will ultimately cause more vigilance concerning Immigrants by the police.

The bill is largely debated because programs such as ICE have been known to cause unnecessary injury to family units and legitimate people seeking asylum from their oppressive home countries. 

“There are so many people both in this body and outside of this body who would be suspected as foreign nationals and would be unfairly detained until it was proven they were citizens,” said Duluth Democrat Rep. Ruwa Romman. 

There are many questions as to what the Immigration bill could mean for immigrants, as it needs to receive edits of clarification with regulations on who may be stopped and how identification is obtained. Not only should the bill be sharpened by representatives before it reaches the Senate, but the public should also be better informed on whether or not the bill will only affect individuals in jail. These clarifications could alleviate the stress of immigrants and help the bill gain support by a larger number of people.

The bill as it stands needs work in order to truly serve the purpose it states to do, however turning the death of a poor girl into a political spectacle by blaming all illegal immigrants as dangerous should not sit right with individuals.

 It is important for individuals to recognize both the troubles that immigrants face to come to the United States and the tragedy of the Laken Riley killing, because without understanding the luck that U.S. Citizens carry just by living in America, it is easy to slip up and harm immigrants through passing laws that one does not understand the gravity of.

Donate to The Trail - The Student News Site of McIntosh High School
$665
$2000
Contributed
Our Goal

Your donation supports the student journalists of McIntosh High School. Your contribution allows us to cover our annual website hosting costs, to have access to Reuters images for international and national news and feature stories, to purchase more and updated equipment such as cameras, lenses, and digital voice recorders, and continuing education for staff, such as SNO training and MediaNow! editorial leadership training.

About the Contributor
Yasemin Kalpakci
Yasemin Kalpakci, Features Editor
Yasemin Kalpakci is a senior at McIntosh High School and currently serves as the Features Editor for the McIntosh Trail. She joined the Trail staff in early 2024 and was part of the staff that won the SNO Distinguished Site Award in both the 2023-2024 and 2024-2025 school years.  In addition to her journalism accomplishments, Kalpakci has also achieved success in other areas. She won a nation-wide best of SNO award for her story, “McIntosh honors Vinny, the service dog of teacher and veteran Christopher Judy.” Kalpakci also won an All-Georgia award for her Critical Review, “Opinion: ‘I was a bad girl’ but was she?” and a Superior in Health/Medical Reporting with, “SOS: ending the stigma around finding help.” In addition to her journalism accomplishments, Kalpakci has also achieved success in other areas. Her art has been published on the board of education in the 2023-2024 school year.  Kalpakci has been involved in the Beta Club since elementary school and is an active volunteer at animal shelters and various school activities. She was instrumental in creating her old school’s World Food Club, promoting cultural exchange through food.  Outside of school, Kalpakci enjoys listening to Lana Del Rey, reading AO3, binge-watching Gilmore Girls, and spending hours on Pinterest. Like many high school students, she’s uncertain about her future plans but hopes to figure it out soon.
Donate to The Trail - The Student News Site of McIntosh High School
$665
$2000
Contributed
Our Goal