“Big Controversy”

In the saga of Sept. 8’s spirit night, was the theme “white-out” or “neon?”
The confusion surrounding the Sept. 8 theme night led to a student section covering their bases of a mix of white and neon colors.
The confusion surrounding the Sept. 8 theme night led to a student section covering their bases of a mix of white and neon colors.
Camilla O’Connell

The week of Sep. 4, there was confusion between administration and the student section ahead of the McIntosh Chiefs’ home football game against Central High School on Sep. 8. The McIntosh Chiefs official Instagram page posted the theme “neon” and McIntosh Student Section Instagram page posted “white out” for the game. 

“I was very confused the entire time,” junior Zoe Mitchell said. 

Screenshot from the official MHS Instagram page announcing the spirit night theme.

The confusion began the day of the game, when McIntosh student section socials posted that the theme would be “white out, where all students dress in white apparel.” The official McIntosh Chiefs Instagram, run by administration, posted a video of the senior section leaders James Hooper and Ava Guest, saying that the theme of the game would be “neon,” causing an hours-long back-and-forth of social media communication among students and leaving them unsure of their outfit plans for the football game. 

“I don’t want to be the only people showing up in neon, while all the other kids are showing up in white,” a sophomore, who wished their identity be withheld, said. 

Story continues below advertisement

Even though the original theme for the game came from administration’s annoucement was neon, some students preferred white-out as the theme. Students ended up showing up to the game in the theme they thought was best, resulting in a student section that was a mixture of neon and white out apparel. 

“We had a big controversy. Originally it was neon and then some people wanted white-out,” senior student section leader James Hooper said. 

The confusion surrounding the Sept. 8 theme night led to a student section covering their bases of a mix of white and neon colors. (Camilla O’Connell)

The 2024 senior class Snapchat argued over the theme of the game. Some seniors preferred white out because the football team would be wearing their white jerseys and wanted to represent the team. 

“Most people were for white-out and then they were starting to get mad because admin said no,” a senior who was part of the group chat and wished their identity be withheld, said. 

The students in the senior group chat had mixed reviews for both football game themes. 

“Majority wanted white out, minority wanted neon and those middle ones that were just like, ‘Let’s just do both,’” an anonymous McIntosh senior said. 

Majority wanted white out, minority wanted neon and those middle ones that were just like, ‘Let’s just do both.”

Junior Sophie Castellon, who showed up to the game wearing a combination of white and neon, was one such student. Castellon wore a white top with multi-colored cargo pants.

“It’s very confusing but I just wore both,” Castellon said.

This situation brings to light the issue of who really chooses the football game theme, the seniors or the administration.

“The seniors have been choosing the themes for so long. Like, what’s the point in changing it now?” the senior said. 

On an Instagram story poll, the Trail asked followers, “Should students or admin determine the game themes?” Forty-three voters chose “Students” while “Admin” received no votes. Five respondents suggested “Both.”

Screenshot of the Trail’s Instagram poll, “Should students or admin determine the game themes?”

“There has never been a bad theme;  everyone has always liked it,” the senior said. 

The Chiefs fell to Central, 21 to 40, and the Chiefs play Landmark Christian Academy in an away game that begins at Landmark at 7:30 p.m.

The next home game is the Homecoming game on Oct. 6.

Donate to McIntosh Trail - The Student News Site of McIntosh High School
$350
$500
Contributed
Our Goal

Your donation supports the student journalists of McIntosh High School. Your contribution will allow us to purchase photography equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.

About the Contributors
Grace Lovejoy
Grace Lovejoy, Features Editor
Grace Lovejoy is serving as the Features Editor for the McIntosh Trail this year. Lovejoy is a sophomore this year and ia McIntosh Ambassador and a Gold Honor Roll Student. Lovejoy first started journalism In sixth grade at J.C Booth Middle School working for the online newsletter. She joined the Mcintosh Trail last year and was promoted to Features Editor as a sophomore. Last year, Lovejoy won the Trail staff’s first Best of SNO Excellence in writing badge for her story “Collision course: teens and golf cart accidents in Peachtree City”. In the fall, she followed and wrote multiple stories about Taylor Swift vs. Ticketmaster. At the Georgia Scholastic Press Association’s Spring Convention, she won a superior in depth news story award for her story, “The Saga of Taylor Swift Tickets: “The Great War '' between fans and Ticketmaster”. Lovejoy is now seeing her first year as a New Voices Student Leader at the Student Press Law Center for the 2023-2024 school year. She also applied to Teen Insight, a fully teen-run student online newspaper created by New Voices Leaders. Last year, Lovejoy was a part of the McIntosh Drama Department’s one act and the McIntosh Girls Varsity Tennis Team. Lovejoy loves journaling, organizing and acting. She is very excited to help new staffers have a successful first year of highschool journalism!
Camilla O’Connell
Camilla O'Connell is a McIntosh Student Media member who contributes to the Trail photography.
Donate to McIntosh Trail - The Student News Site of McIntosh High School
$350
$500
Contributed
Our Goal